What Evidence Do I Need To Win a Personal Injury Case?
Winning a personal injury case starts with clarity and preparation. The right evidence tells your story, what happened, how you were hurt, and why the other party is responsible. With strong documentation and the right legal help, you can build a case that leads to real recovery and peace of mind.
Key Summary:
You must prove fault, causation, injuries, and damages with credible records.
Start collecting photos, medical care proof, and witness info as soon as you can.
Do not post about your case on social media. It can be used against you.
A Denver trial lawyer protects evidence, deals with insurers, and builds the case for settlement or trial.
Why Evidence Is the Foundation of Your Case
Evidence is what turns your story into proof in a personal injury lawsuit. It shows how the accident happened, who the liable party is, and what your physical injuries have cost you emotionally, financially, and in quality of life. Without solid evidence, insurance companies and courts have little to rely on.
The strength of your personal injury case depends on how well you meet the burden of proof, what you can clearly show through crucial evidence, not just what you say. Photos, witness statements, medical records, and bills all work together to show negligence and loss.
An experienced trial lawyer knows how to collect, preserve physical evidence, and present valuable documents before they disappear, a key part of the legal process in personal injury law.
From securing surveillance footage to interviewing witnesses and consulting experts, your attorney connects the dots so your case stands strong in front of a jury or at the settlement table.
What Evidence Do You Need To Win a Personal Injury Case?
You need evidence that shows fault, connects your injuries to the incident, and proves your damages. This includes visual proof, medical documentation, witness testimony, and records of financial loss. Together, this valuable evidence forms the backbone of your claim and helps build a strong personal injury case that meets the preponderance of the evidence standard. In other words, you need to show the court that it’s more likely than not that the other person’s actions caused your injuries.
Here are the key types of evidence to gather:
Photos and Videos
Photos and videos tell your story clearly. They show what the accident scene looked like, how vehicles were positioned, and any visible hazards or injuries.
These visuals help explain how the accident happened and who was at fault.
Take wide shots for context and close-ups for details like skid marks or broken glass. Use timestamps if you can. For car crashes, photograph both vehicles, signs, and traffic lights.
If you couldn’t take photos right away, go back as soon as possible. A personal injury lawyer can also find surveillance footage from nearby cameras before it’s deleted.
Police or Incident Reports
Police reports provide an official record of what happened and who was involved. They often include diagrams, witness names, and officer notes that support your account.
Request a copy as soon as it’s ready. In workplace or store cases, ask for an internal incident report. These reports confirm timelines and may reveal if safety rules were ignored.
Your attorney will review them for accuracy and look for additional evidence or witnesses.
Medical Records and Bills
Medical records carry significant weight in any personal injury lawsuit. They show what physical injuries you suffered, the medical attention you received, and how your life has changed as a result.
Keep everything, including ER visits, x-rays, therapy notes, and prescriptions. Medical bills prove the financial cost of your care. Even small receipts count.
A complete medical file helps your lawyer link the accident to your injuries and show your physical and financial losses.
Witness Statements
Witnesses can confirm what happened and strengthen your version of events. Their accounts may include details you missed or disprove false claims from the other side.
Try to get names and contact information right away. If you can’t, your personal injury lawyer can find them later. Attorneys know how to collect statements that are accurate, detailed, and credible for court or settlement.
Employment and Income Records
If your injury caused you to miss work or lose income, these relevant documents are key to proving negligence and showing the financial impact of your case. Pay stubs, tax returns, and letters from your employer show how much you lost.
If you’re self-employed, use invoices, bank statements, or business records instead. Your lawyer may also bring in an economist to estimate future income loss.
Organized records help your attorney prove both current and future financial damage.
Expert Opinions
Experts help make complicated information easy to understand. Their opinions connect your injuries and losses to the accident.
Doctors can explain your treatment and its long-term impact. Accident reconstructionists can show how the crash or fall occurred.
Financial experts can calculate lost wages or future expenses. Experienced lawyers know which experts carry weight in court and how to present their findings clearly.
Personal Journals
A pain journal gives a human side to your injury. Write short notes about pain levels, movement limits, emotions, and daily challenges.
Keep entries consistent and honest. Over time, they help show how the injury changed your routine and well-being. Personal injury attorneys often use journals to support claims for pain and suffering.
Physical Evidence
Physical objects can be strong proof of what happened. Damaged clothing, safety gear, or a broken product can show the impact or cause of your injury.
Store everything safely and don’t repair or throw anything away. If the evidence is large, your lawyer can document or store it professionally. Even small items can make a big difference in showing fault or injury severity.
Digital Evidence
Digital evidence captures what happened in real time. Surveillance cameras, dashcams, or smartphone data can show how the accident occurred.
Act quickly; many recordings are deleted within days. Your lawyer can request copies before that happens. GPS or phone records can also reveal distraction or location. Digital proof is powerful because it’s objective and time-stamped, showing exactly what took place.
The Four Pillars You Must Prove
Most personal injury cases rests on four pillars. If even one is weak, your claim can suffer. Clear, well-documented evidence supports each element.
Duty and Breach of Duty (Negligence)
The first step is to prove that the other party had a legal duty to act safely and failed to do so. For example, drivers must follow traffic laws, and property owners must keep their premises safe.
Evidence that helps: scene photos, witness statements, safety records, company maintenance logs, and any prior complaints or violations.
These details show what should have been done, and wasn’t.
Causation
You must connect the negligent act to your injury. This means proving that your pain or condition directly resulted from the accident, not something else.
Evidence that helps: emergency room notes, imaging results, consistent medical follow-ups, and expert testimony linking the mechanism of injury to the event.
The more consistent your documentation, the harder it is for insurers to dispute.
Injuries
Next, you must show what harm you suffered and how it affects your life. This includes both visible and internal injuries, as well as emotional distress or reduced quality of life.
Evidence that helps: medical records, doctor’s notes, surgery or therapy reports, prescriptions, and before-and-after photos.
Detailed records of pain levels, daily struggles, and recovery progress can also strengthen your claim.
Damages
Finally, you need proof of the financial and personal losses caused by your injury. This includes medical expenses, lost wages, and non-economic damages like pain and suffering.
Evidence that helps: pay stubs, tax returns, receipts for out-of-pocket costs, repair estimates, and professional evaluations for future care needs.
Keeping an organized folder for every bill, prescription, and expense makes it easier for your attorney to calculate fair compensation.
Core Evidence Checklist By Category
Every piece of evidence plays a role in proving your case. Below is a quick guide to what each type of proof shows, how it helps, and how your attorney uses it to strengthen your claim.
| Evidence Type | Example Use | Recommended Frequency | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Photos & Videos | Scene details, property damage, and visible injuries | Your phone, dashcam, surveillance footage | Shows how the accident happened and who was at fault |
| Police or Incident Reports | Official account of the event and involved parties | Law enforcement, property owners, or employers | Confirms fault and provides witness and timeline details |
| Medical Records & Bills | Injury type, treatment, and medical costs | Hospitals, clinics, and doctors | Proves the link between the incident and your injuries |
| Witness Statements | Independent confirmation of events | Bystanders, coworkers, or passengers | Adds credibility and supports your version of what happened |
| Employment & Income Records | Wage loss and reduced earning capacity | Employer, payroll department, or tax filings | Calculates economic damages for fair compensation |
| Expert Reports | Professional opinions on fault, injury, and costs | Doctors, accident reconstructionists, economists | Strengthens technical aspects of your case |
| Physical Evidence | Tangible proof of the accident or injury | Damaged items, tools, or safety equipment | Demonstrates impact, force, or product defects |
| Digital Evidence | Recordings and data from devices or systems | Security footage, black box data, phone logs | Provides objective, time-stamped proof |
| Personal Journals | Impact on daily life and mental health | Your own notes and reflections | Supports pain and suffering claims with personal detail |
Personal Injury Evidence By Case Type
Different accidents require different forms of proof. Each type of case has unique evidence that helps your attorney show exactly what went wrong and who’s responsible.
Car Accidents
Car accident cases rely on showing how the crash happened and who caused it. Important proof includes crash reports, dashcam or traffic footage, photos of both vehicles, skid marks, and black box (EDR) data.
Medical records and witness statements connect your injuries to the collision. Your personal injury lawyer may also request phone or toxicology records if distraction or impairment played a role.
Truck Accidents
Truck crashes involve more documentation and strict federal rules. Key evidence includes driver logbooks, hours-of-service records, ELD data, inspection reports, and company maintenance logs.
Bills of lading and dispatch sheets can reveal unsafe schedules or company pressure. Quick action is vital because preserving evidence is time-sensitive; trucking companies often delete or overwrite crucial data soon after an accident.
Motorcycle Accidents
Motorcycle accident claims often focus on visibility and road conditions. Helpful proof includes helmet and gear damage, photos of road hazards, dashcam or GoPro footage, and reconstruction reports.
Witness statements can confirm that another driver failed to yield or see the rider in time.
Pedestrian Accidents
Pedestrian cases require showing visibility, driver attention, and traffic conditions. Useful evidence includes crosswalk or intersection camera footage, police diagrams, and driver statements.
Medical imaging and footwear photos can show impact direction. Personal injury lawyers may also examine lighting or road design to prove unsafe conditions.
Bicycle Accidents
Bike accident evidence often combines road details with equipment condition. Photos of potholes, damaged helmets or bikes, and driver reports all help.
Data from cycling apps or GPS devices can verify your speed and route. Witness statements are also key to proving that a driver failed to share the road safely.
Slip and Fall Accidents
Slip and fall claims depend on proving negligence by the property owner and showing that the liable party failed to maintain safe conditions. Key evidence includes incident reports, cleaning or maintenance logs, and surveillance footage.
Photos of spills, ice, or clutter are crucial. Experts may review lighting or flooring to show poor upkeep. Act fast, as many businesses erase security footage within a few days.
Common Mistakes That Weaken Evidence
Even a strong personal injury case can be weakened by small oversights. Avoid these common mistakes to preserve evidence and protect your right to seek compensation.
Delaying medical care.
Waiting to see a doctor makes it easier for insurers to argue that your injuries aren’t serious or connected to the accident.
Not documenting everything.
Skipping photos, missing receipts, or failing to track symptoms can weaken your damages claim.
Posting on social media.
Pictures or updates can be used against you, even if they seem harmless.
Discarding physical evidence.
Throwing away damaged items or repairing them too soon can remove key proof.
Ignoring witness follow-up.
Witnesses can move or forget details quickly; make sure contact information is recorded early.
Talking to insurance adjusters without counsel.
Insurers often use your statements to minimize payouts or shift blame.
Failing to preserve digital evidence.
Videos and emails are often deleted within days unless preserved by an experienced personal injury attorney.
How a Trial Lawyer Builds Your Evidence File
An experienced trial lawyer knows that evidence wins cases, not opinions. Their job is to uncover, protect, and organize every piece of proof that tells your story.
From day one, your attorney focuses on gathering documents, tracking down witnesses, and preserving time-sensitive records that may otherwise disappear.
Your law firm and its team will carefully manage the legal process by:
Visit the scene and take new photos or videos if needed.
Interview witnesses, first responders, and experts to understand what really happened.
Collect medical records and coordinate with your doctors to connect your injuries to the event.
Send preservation letters to businesses, trucking companies, or property owners to secure surveillance footage.
Review financial records, bills, and employment data to calculate your total losses.
Every document, image, and statement becomes part of your “evidence file.” This file is what your lawyer uses to negotiate with insurance companies or present a clear, powerful case in court.
At Fiedler Trial Lawyers, we take pride in handling this process personally. You will work directly with an experienced trial attorney who listens, communicates clearly, and fights for you from start to finish.
We work on a no-fee unless you win, so you pay nothing upfront.
Conclusion
Strong evidence is the backbone of every successful personal injury case.
Photos, reports, witness accounts, and medical documentation help prove fault, link your injuries to the accident, and show the full extent of your losses. The sooner you act, the easier it is to protect your rights and preserve the proof that matters most.
If you have been injured and need help collecting or understanding the evidence for your case, Fiedler Trial Lawyers is ready to help.
With 25+ years of trial experience and millions recovered for clients, our team never stops fighting for you.
Contact us today for a free case review; you pay no fees unless we recover for you.
FAQs
How much evidence do I need for a personal injury case?
You need enough to prove fault, causation, and damages. Quality matters more than quantity. Clear, consistent records are more persuasive than a large stack of disorganized documents.
Do I need expert witnesses to win my case?
In cases involving serious injuries, product defects, or disputed fault, expert witnesses can be essential. They explain complex information in simple terms and help the jury understand how the accident caused your injuries.
What if I don’t have photos or videos of the accident?
That’s okay. Other evidence, like witness statements, medical reports, and police records, can still build a strong case. Your lawyer may also locate security or traffic footage before it’s erased.
How long do I have to gather evidence before filing?
In Colorado, you generally have two years to file most personal injury claims (three for auto accidents). But many types of evidence, like video or electronic data, can be lost within days. Acting quickly helps preserve your case.
How fast do I need to act to preserve video from a store or truck?
You should act as soon as possible. Most stores keep their security footage for only a few days to a few weeks before it’s recorded over or deleted. Trucking companies must save their electronic driving logs for six months, but video dashcams or inside the truck might get erased. An experienced personal injury lawyer can send a preservation letter to secure it before it’s gone.
More Frequently
Asked Questions
If you’ve been injured in an accident, there are several important steps you should take to protect your health and legal rights
- Dial 911 – Emergency Services. Get checked out by emergency responders, even if you think injuries are minor, you should always get evaluated. If the accident involved a motor vehicle, file a report with the police This documentation could be important later on.
- Document the Scene: If possible, take photos of the accident scene, your injuries, and any damage to vehicles or property. Collect contact information from witnesses and others involved in the accident READ MORE…
When involved in a personal injury claim, the process can be very intimidating. Many individuals facing this situation are often dealing with life-altering injuries, high medical bills, financial hardships and find themselves feeling very vulnerable.
Hiring a personal injury lawyer can be beneficial in a variety of situations, particularly when you have sustained significant injuries or damages due to someone else’s negligenceREAD MORE…
After being injured in an accident caused by someone else’s negligence, you may be wondering if you actually need to hire a personal injury lawyer. You would want to consult with an attorney, because in most cases, there will be an opposing party in your case that will be working against you. Choosing the right personal injury lawyer for your case is important to ensure you receive the best possible representation and outcome. Hiring a Denver Personal injury lawyer that specializes in that area of law is crucial, to ensure that you are getting proper representation, and your case is in good hands. Having an experienced lawyer like FIEDLER Trial Lawyers is helpful and provides powerful representation.
Here are some tips to help you choose the right lawyer:READ MORE…
The cost of hiring a personal injury lawyer can vary depending on the lawyer and the specifics of your case. However, personal injury lawyers work on a contingency fee basis, which means they only get paid if they win your case. Here’s how the contingency fee structure typically works and other potential costs to consider:
Contingency Fees: Percentage of Recovery: If the lawyer works on a contingency fee basis, they will take a percentage of the settlement or judgment amount you receive if you win your case. This percentage is typically around 33% to 40% but can vary depending on the lawyer and the jurisdiction.
No Win, No Fee: If you do not win your case, the lawyer will not charge you for legal fees. However, there may still be other costs you could be responsible for (discussed below).RAED MORE…
In a personal injury claim, you may be entitled to several types of compensation, also known as damages, to address the losses and injuries you’ve suffered due to someone else’s negligence or wrongdoing. The types of compensation typically fall into three main categories: economic, non-economic, and, in some cases, punitive damages. Here’s an overview of each:
Economic Damages: These damages are intended to compensate you for actual financial losses resulting from the injury:
Medical Expenses: Compensation for past, current, and future medical costs, including hospital bills, surgeries, medications, rehabilitation, and any other necessary medical treatment. READ MORE…
The value of a personal injury case can vary greatly depending on several factors unique to your situation. Since each case is different, there is no standard formula to calculate the exact value. However, here are some key factors that generally affect the worth of a personal injury case:
Severity of Injuries: The more serious and long-lasting your injuries, the higher the potential value of your case. This includes considering whether your injuries result in permanent disability or disfigurement.
Medical Expenses: Your case will take into account all medical expenses you have incurred, as well as future medical costs related to your injury.
Lost Wages and Earning Capacity: The case can include compensation for lost income due to time off work and any future loss of earning capacity if your injuries affect your ability to work.READ MORE…
Our Client’s Say It Best
directly from our own clients.
Car accidents are not fun. However, Ken and his team took great care of our family EVERY STEP of the way. From chiropractic car, probate court, insurance negotiations with multiple companies, advice for our family, and collaboration on action items, Ken & team were awesome. I will be sending family and friends to Ken in the future. Thank you for taking great care of my family!
If I could give 10 stars I would! Ken and his team were there for me during the worst time of my life, every step of the way. I had 3 different friends recommend Ken after my car accident and I’m so grateful they did! He always explained everything clearly, walked me through every step, and gave me clear expectations. I was nervous, never having entered into the legal world before, but he made sure I felt safe and supported through the entire process, sending me flowers before surgery, checking in and giving me updates frequently. I never wish anyone to be in a situation like I was but if you find yourself in need of representation Ken and his team are the ones you want! Thank you to Ginger, James and Jahieda as well for always being there for me!
I suffered a spine injury as the result of a T-bone car crash, the other driver at fault. We got nothing but gutter-ball offers from her insurance company. What you hear on the radio is true – the insurance companies simply will not take your case seriously until you file a suit. This is where I was glad to have Ken and his team on my side. The burden to convince a jury of my losses lies with me the plaintiff, which then requires conducting extensive research, gathering and organizing supporting documents. After Ken submitted all of this material during the pre-trial discovery the insurance company decided to make a reasonable settlement offer.
We make it simple. No time for a phone call now? Complete this form and we will schedule a call at your convenience. Your information is confidential.
4725 S. Monaco Street, Suite 120
Denver, CO 80237
Phone: 720-996-6000
1800 Wazee Street, Suite 300
Denver, CO 80202
77 West Wacker Drive, Suite 4500
Chicago, IL 60601
Phone: 312-788-2600
KEN FIEDLER | 303.CALL.KEN